Hiked through the Mt Toby Forest over to the cave on a Saturday. The parking lot was mostly full with cars parked along the road. The trails were moderately trafficked and the cave itself had a group of people repelling down. We hiked out to the cave, through the cave from the northern entrance, and out to the southern entrance which sits along the edge of the mountain. The inside of the cave is virtually pitch-black with a few scraps of light shining in from above and the side entrances. If you plan to explore the cave, you must bring a headlamp or a powerful flashlight. One side of the cave has a sheer 7-foot drop-off with rock ledges you can use to get up/down, but watch your footing and grip. Also watch your head while inside the cave since the headroom is low. The entire cave itself is roughly 25 to 30-feet long and about 20 feet deep at the center. The hike itself is moderate and you can follow well-marked signs to reach the cave.
The trail was extremely wet within the first 0.5-miles from the trailhead. Some parts of the trail were essentially creeks flowing slowly downhill. Just before the last 0.1-miles of the hike, just before the campsite, was an enormous stagnant section of water that required slow traversing to get around without falling in or sinking your feet into. The campsite was dry and the creek that flows through it did not flood the campsite like the rest of the trail. The lookout point on the way up was a nice break from the 2.5-mile hike in with packs. Hiked with Nina, Jax, Tony (HikingUpward), and Linda (HikingUpward).
Hiked out beyond the ridge campsite to the lookout point and back to the South Prong Trail. Mostly an easy hike. Amazing views into the distant mountains with an additional view of Seneca Rocks below. Hiked with Nina, Jax, Tony (HikingUpward), and Linda (HikingUpward).