Buttermilk Falls via Mister Rogers' Pathway

40.419237, -79.067842

The Buttermilk Falls via Mister Roger's Pathway at the Buttermilk Falls Natural Area in New Florence, PA, is an easy 0.4 mile loop hike that brings you down to the waterfall.

At approximately 46-feet tall, Buttermilk Falls is the tallest waterfall in western Pennsylvania and is a popular destination for locals, folks living in the Greater Pittsburgh Area, and road trip travelers alike.

This area was previously owned by Fred McFeely, grandfather of Fred Rogers. There's a lookout area above the waterfall and in 2017 a ramp was built leading down to the base of the falls; however, this recording does not reflect those updates yet.

Pets

Dogs are allowed on leash here.

Prohibited

Ice climbing is not allowed at Buttermilk Falls.

Parking & How to Get To Buttermilk Falls

Visitors will find two small parking lots at the coordinates provided, located at the end of Valley Brook Road in New Florence, Pennsylvania. The lots are large enough to fit about 12 vehicles (max) as of February 2026.

Know Before You Go

Buttermilk Falls via Mister Rogers' Pathway is an easy, 0.4-mile loop in New Florence, PA leading to a 46-foot waterfall, the tallest in western PA.
The area has a connection to Fred Rogers (Mister Rogers) as it was previously owned by his grandfather.
The trail now features a ramp to the base of the falls (built in 2017), and dogs are allowed on leashes.

Weather Forecast

Loading...

<strong>Trail map and elevation chart not rendering in print mode?</strong> Simply scroll to the trail map section, then try printing again!

Total Change

85'

Ascent

61'

Descent

110'

Loading...

Features

Vista / Lookout Point

Dogs

Waterfalls

Points of interest

Parking

40.419237, -79.067842
Copy
Main Trailhead

40.419169, -79.067711
Copy

Safety information

For your own safety: plan ahead, let someone know where you'll be, and hike at your own risk.

Hazards

Lyme and Other Tickborne Diseases (CDC)

Availability

Spring

Surface type

Dirt

Trip Reports (Reviews)
Routes

Trip Reports (Reviews)

Rated 5.0 out of 5 based on 1 rating.

Ready to help fellow hikers? Add a trip report to share your experience and provide valuable insights for other hikers!

David Miller (Admin)

0.4 miles / 0.6 km

February 14, 2026

First time visiting the waterfall since prior to the bridge and staircase installation. Beautiful ~40-foot tall cascade, frozen over. Popular spot now.

Hiking Dogs